TFSA vs. RRSP: Where to Start Saving for Retirement

By Rubina Ahmed-Haq on January 23, 2017 No Comments

After landing your first full time job the advice is often to start saving for retirement. Now it can be hard to convince a young person to put money away for an event that’s 40 years in the future. But what can be even more difficult is understanding where to save that hard earned cash.  In Canada there are two excellent tax efficient ways to save for retirement.  There’s the traditional Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) and since 2009 there’s the Tax Free Savings Account (TFSA).  Both offer a fantastic technique to grow your money. Before deciding what is best for you, is to first understand how these two registered savings vehicles work.

RRSP 101

Money contributed to an RRSP can be deducted from your taxable income. For example, if you contribute $2000 to your RRSP and you gross annual salary was $50,000, you could reduce your taxable income to $48,000. You wouldn’t have to pay federal income tax on the $2000.  The money in the RRSP grows tax frees, so if your investment are doing well you’re also not required to pay capital gains. It also works the other way, if your investments lose money you can’t claim capital losses if you sell. With the RRSP you will pay income tax on the money you withdraw in retirement. The logic is your income bracket will be much lower at this time then during your working life resulting in an overall smaller tax burden.

TFSA 101

When it comes to your TFSA your investments also grow tax free. The money you contribute is after tax dollars and does not reduce your taxable income. The bonus is when you withdraw the money you don’t have to pay any income tax on your gains. For example your investment could double and you can withdraw that tax free.

When the RRSP makes sense

Making an RRSP contribution makes more financial sense when you’re at your highest earning bracket. If you just landed your first job chances are you will earn more in the future. Using the previous example a $2000 RRSP contribution on a gross annual income of $50,000 would result in a tax savings of $593. But if you income was $100,000 that same contribution represents $869 in tax savings. That is 30% more money in your pocket with the same amount of money saved.

How do you choose?

If you want to get the full tax benefit, you can do two things.

If you believe you will be earning more later in your career, use your TFSA in the beginning to save for your retirement. The money will grow tax free. Once you are at your highest earning you could withdraw that money and contribute it to your RRSP, providing there is enough contribution room.

The other option is to continue to contribute to your RRSP but don’t claim the contribution until you are earning more (and paying more tax). It is a common misconception that you have to claim the contribution you made in the year you made it.

For those who forecast their income remaining in a lower tax bracket. The more tax efficient move may be to use your TFSA to save for retirement. You won’t get the tax benefit when you are saving. But in retirement you can withdraw the money tax free and without it affecting your other government benefits and credits.

Generally those who fall into a lower income tax bracket should take full advantage of the TFSA. This year you can contribute up to $5500. But those in the higher income brackets should focus more on RRSP contribution as the tax benefits is greater the more you make. Regardless of what you choose the fact that retirement saving is a priority means you’re already on the right track to a wealthy future.

Image Credit: 401(K) 2012

Rubina Ahmed-Haq

Rubina Ahmed-Haq is a Journalist and Personal Finance Expert. She is the go-to money expert in Canada for several media outlets. She regularly appears on CBC Radio, CBC News Network, CTV Your Morning and Global Toronto. She writes for Homes Publishing group,, and has her own website Rubina began her career as a broadcast journalist in 1999. Since then she has covered everything from local news, foreign affairs, politics, sports and of course finance! As a business reporter she has worked for CP24 from the Toronto Stock Exchange and reported for BNN. Her work has also appeared in the Toronto Star and various other magazines. She has a Bachelor of Arts degree from York University and is an alumna of the Humber College post graduate journalism program and holds the CSC designation. Her goal is to help Canadians find easy ways to manage their own finances. Follow her on Twitter @alwayssavemoney.

Top Tips for First Time Home Buyers

By Rubina Ahmed-Haq on April 26, 2017

This is the busiest time for real estate transactions in Canada. If you’re out shopping for a home it’s easy to get caught up and spend more than you wanted too. For first time homebuyers it can be an overwhelming experience. Before setting out to buy your first home here are a few ways you…

How Diversifying Your Transportation Habits Can Save You Thousands

By Jordann Brown on April 17, 2017

If you grew up with two cars in your parents’ driveway, you’re not alone. Like most Canadians, the generation before us spent thousands of dollars per year maintaining their vehicles, fueling them up and paying for them through car loans. For our parents, cars were a sign of freedom, mobility, and independence. Fast forward 20…

How to Budget For Summer Holidays

By Alyssa Davies on March 29, 2017

I know what you’re thinking – summer seems way too far away to be worrying about what lies ahead. However, that is exactly why you need to start planning and prepping for any upcoming expenses. Not unlike Christmastime, summer travel and events can end up being just as costly. Wedding season rolls around, camping trips…

Which Type of Debt Should You Repay First?

By Amanda Reaume on March 23, 2017

Some people feel very anxious when they’re in debt and want to pay it off as soon as possible. But if you have a lot of debt or if you have many different types of debt, then you might be confused as to which debt you should pay off first. The first thing that you…

No Comments Leave a Comment  

Leave a Comment

Free Savings Estimate

How much do you owe?


Live Chat
Welcome to our Live Chat
Agents are not available at this time. Please leave a message. Thank you.
First Name
Last Name
Postal Code
Debt Amount
PHP Live! powered